Anonymous no longer

Judge: Newspaper must provide information leading to identity of blog commenter

Print Article

COEUR d'ALENE - A judge on Tuesday ruled that the Spokesman-Review must give a local Republican leader information that could lead to the identity of an anonymous commenter who posted to one of the newspaper's blogs.

The former chair of the Kootenai County Republican Party Central Committee, Tina Jacobson, wants the name because she believes the person defamed her by suggesting she stole $10,000 from the local party.

The newspaper tried to quash Jacobson's subpoena for the information, but in a 24-page written ruling 1st District Court Judge John Luster decided she's entitled to it.

Jacobson's subpoena also sought the identity of two other anonymous commenters on the Spokesman-Review blog, Huckleberries Online. The newspaper doesn't have to provide identifying information for those two.

Jacobson believes the other two are witnesses to the alleged defamation on Feb. 14 by commenter "almostinnocentbystander."

All three made comments below a photograph posted to Huckleberries Online showing former presidential candidate Rick Santorum's visit to Coeur d'Alene. Jacobson could be seen in the background of the photograph.

Huckleberries Online is administered by longtime Spokesman-Review journalist Dave Oliveria, who deleted the comment about $10,000, but it had been visible for 2 1/2 hours.

Luster also ordered the newspaper to provide a document confirming that "almostinnocentbystander" has not been re-established as a commenter on Spokesman-Review blogs.

The ruling said the newspaper must provide to Jacobson a copy of any communication between the Spokesman-Review's employees and "almostinnocentbystander."

The other two commenters used the names "Phaedrus" and "OutofStaterTater" on the newspaper's website.

"Phaedrus" fired off a quick comment on Huckleberries Online after the ruling was filed: "So that's what happened? I was hoping to have a chance to tell Tina and her attorneys to kiss my bum. Ah well, another day, perhaps."

The newspaper has 14 days to comply with Luster's ruling.

"We're in the process of evaluating (the ruling)," said Cowles Publishing Co. and Spokesman-Review attorney Duane Swinton. "We'll make our minds up on what we're going to do after that."

On the Spokesman-Review's website Tuesday night, reporter Thomas Clouse quoted the newspaper's editor, Gary Graham, as saying he has not decided whether to pursue an appeal.

Jacobson's attorney, C. Matthew Andersen, said the ruling is the first step in clearing Jacobson's "good name."

"(The ruling) restates the long-standing legal rule that there is no constitutional protected speech that is defamatory," Andersen said.

He said Luster found Jacobson has shown evidence of "per se defamation and she would prevail on the record filed."

Asked what the plan is now, Andersen said, "The court's order is the court's order. Ms. Jacobson intends to proceed in accord with the judge's order."

Print Article

Read More Political

AP Exclusive: Clinton book has sold more than 300,000 copies

AP

September 20, 2017 at 7:12 am | NEW YORK (AP) Hillary Clinton's "What Happened" had a big debut. Clinton's book about her stunning loss in 2016 to Donald Trump sold more than 300,000 copies in the combined formats of hardcove...

Comments

Read More

GOP governors launch 'news' site critics call propaganda

AP

September 19, 2017 at 8:50 am | ATLANTA (AP) Republican governors are getting into the "news" business. The Republican Governors Association has quietly launched an online publication that looks like a media outlet and is bra...

Comments

Read More

States ask insurers to prioritize non-opioid pain treatment

AP

September 18, 2017 at 3:18 pm | CHERRY HILL, N.J. (AP) Attorneys general representing the majority of states asked health insurers Monday to encourage pain treatment through means other than prescriptions for opioid painkillers, ...

Comments

Read More

Michigan doctor believes US ready for first Muslim governor

AP

September 15, 2017 at 1:58 pm | DETROIT (AP) Perhaps no state has embraced the political outsider as much as Michigan, where a venture capitalist won the last two governor's elections and a real estate baron carried the president...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(208) 664-8176
215 N. Second St
Coeur d'Alene, Idaho 83814

©2017 The Coeur d'Alene Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X