Reasons to change county’s government

Print Article

There has been a great deal of discussion on changing the form of county government to five part-time commissioners and a full-time manager. Many people know little about this so it might be worthwhile to take a closer look.

I know Dan Green and while we may not agree on everything, I found him to be a capable administrator and a good friend. I support the changes that have been proposed and believe we should again place this before the voters.

This type of governance is relatively common and used throughout the United States. Local examples are Coeur díAlene, Post Falls, Rathdrum, and Hayden. Itís nothing new and has been around for a long time and is a very successful approach to governance while still providing effective public participation. I have never heard anyone suggest that we change the form of government for these communities, while I have heard for years the desire to change county government.

Our county commissioners endure meeting after meeting after meeting. Itís a wonder they get time to breathe. Having a full-time county manager would allow the commissioners time to focus on long-term policies and planning for the future.

Hiring a coroner, clerk, treasurer, and assessor makes good sense. Advertising for and carefully selecting candidates for those jobs based on written job descriptions and qualifications is a tried-and-true approach that any business person can appreciate. How many businesses would consider having an election for their treasurer?

For instance, the assessor in the county is a very important position. What kind of qualifications are needed to do the job? According to Idaho statutes, a candidate must be 21, a citizen, and a resident for at least a year. Once elected, we are bound to that person for four years. Yes, we could recall a bad assessor, but we know how hard that is to do. Wouldnít it make sense to hire based on qualifications? For the record, Mike McDowell is a great assessor and should retain his position. Wouldnít it be nice if he didnít have to worry about party affiliations or campaigns?

It makes sense that county commissioners should be part time and compensated similar to city councilmen or mayors. This would free up funds to hire a professional manager without adding any additional burden to the taxpayers. Commissioners could pursue careers and still lead the county. Most mayors and council members make around $10,000 to $12,000 a year plus benefits. We could have five part-time commissioners for the cost of one and have more widespread representation.

Why is this being proposed?

One of the best reasons for this approach is that it will make our county government more efficient and more responsive. This change has been discussed for many years and has had recommendation from several study groups and ad-hoc committees.

What is the commissioner-manager form, used in so many local governments?

The commissioner-manager form is the system of local government that combines the strong political leadership of elected officials (the county commissioners) with the strong managerial experience of an appointed local government manager. The form establishes a representative system where power is concentrated in the elected commissioners who hire a professionally trained manager to oversee the delivery of public services.

Is it a responsive form of government?

In this form of government, commissioners are the leaders and policy makers, elected to represent Kootenai County and to concentrate on policy issues that are responsive to citizensí needs and wishes. The manager is appointed by the commissioners to carry out policy and ensure that the citizens are being served. If the manager is not responsive to the commissionersí wishes, the Board of County Commissioners has authority to terminate the manager at any time. In that sense, a managerís responsiveness is tested daily.

What is the Board of County Commissionersí function?

The BOCC is the legislative body; its members are the countyís decision makers. Power is centralized in the elected commissioners, who approve the budget and determine the tax rate, among other functions. The BOCC also focuses on the communityís goals, major projects, and such long-term considerations as community growth, land use planning, capital improvement plans, capital financing, and strategic planning. The BOCC hires a professional manager to carry out the administrative responsibilities and supervises the managerís performance.

What is the managerís function?

The manager is hired to serve the Board of County Commissioners and the county and to bring to the county the benefits of training and experience in administering local government projects and programs on behalf of the governing body. The manager prepares a budget for the commissionersí consideration; recruits, hires, and supervises the county staff; serves as the commissionersí chief adviser; and carries out the BOCC policies. Commissioners and citizens count on the manager to provide complete and objective information, pros and cons of the alternatives, and long-term consequences.

What is the cost to the local government of appointing a professional manager?

Many local governments have found that overall costs can be reduced with competent management. Savings can come in the form of reduced operating costs, increased efficiency and productivity, reduced commissionersí salaries, and more effective use of technology. In the current Kootenai County budget there are ample funds in the commissionersí budget to accommodate the managerís salary and benefits with reductions in commissionersí salary and benefits.

Does the manager participate in policy determination?

The manager makes policy recommendations to the BOCC, but the board may or may not adopt them, and may modify the recommendations. The manager is bound by whatever action the BOCC takes.

• ē ē

Collin Coles is a retired city planner who worked in local government for more than 40 years. A Coeur díAlene resident, he now spends most of his time doing important stuff, like fishing and being a grampa.

Print Article

Read More My Turn

Vietnam War made real to student

May 25, 2018 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press I realized recently that a student canít get the real picture of history from the pages of a book. My eyes were opened to the realities of war when I interviewed Lon Renolds, a Vietnam veteran. He wa...


Read More

ROBYN EDWARDS: Bottom line: Make growth pay its way

May 25, 2018 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press Those arriving to enjoy the good life in rural Idaho may celebrate escaping from taxes and regulations. Local regulations in the areas they left probably insured that development at least helped pay ...


Read More

COLLEEN DAHLSEID: Timberlake Fire at critical crossroads

May 25, 2018 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press I sat in solemn disbelief last week at the Timberlake Fire District Commissioners meeting, as Commissioner Robyn Edwards voiced her ďagendaĒ to outsource our EMT services. Those of us who love and l...


Read More

Donít call him ĎCongressmaní just yet; ĎRussí will do

May 23, 2018 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press One of the strangest ironies that came out of the recent primary election is that Russ Fulcher is likely to have a job next year as Idahoís First District congressman, and Congressman Raul Labrador w...


Read More

Contact Us

(208) 664-8176
215 N. Second St
Coeur d'Alene, Idaho 83814

©2018 The Coeur d'Alene Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy