Cd'A: Proud to be a city of vision - Coeur d'Alene Press: My Turn

Cd'A: Proud to be a city of vision

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Friday, September 20, 2013 12:00 am

In the next few months we will be continually bombarded with statements such as Michael Teague's definition of who is running for City Council and Mayor of Coeur d'Alene. He attempted to define anyone other than the far right Mary Souza group as the FAR LEFT. Where did he get the information backing up this statement? Who knows, perhaps out of a hat. Or perhaps in his mind and those of his contemporaries anyone who is for visionary leadership is far left.

Visionary leadership looks at the possibilities; maintenance leadership wants to keep the status quo. It was visionary leadership that brought us the new Library, the Kroc Center, Riverstone, the Education Corridor and now McEuen Park. It brought us a new Police Station, a new Fire Station and an upgrade on the older fire stations.

It was visionary leadership that helped create the Emergency Medical System (EMS) Partnership that makes sure you have an ambulance when you need it. It was visionary leadership that renovated a dying downtown in the early '90s and made it the energetic jewel that it is today. It was visionary leadership that brought us Jobs Plus and 80+ new businesses employing hundreds of people.

We are going to hear a lot about property taxes and keeping them low. How about some facts: The City of Coeur d'Alene has more foregone tax saving than nearly every other city in Idaho. After this budget, that amounts to about $3.1 million. What are foregone taxes? Those are property taxes not taken by leadership over a number of years. That means that when the time came to budget, the Mayor and Council chose not to take the full 3 percent allowed by law. What that also means is that your City Staff are very frugal with your money.

How about your property taxes? I hear often that "All I want you to do is provide Police and Fire protection and fix the streets. Just maintain what we have. That is what I want my property taxes to do."

Well, here is an interesting fact: The income from property taxes in the City of Coeur d'Alene amount to $16,773,620. This year's budget for the Fire Department is $7,930,410. The budget for the Police Department is $10,503,340, totaling $18,433,750. That means that our property taxes are about one million seven hundred thousand dollars short of just covering Police and Fire Protection, two of the most important public safety functions that the City provides. We are fortunate to have other sources of income such as our share of sales and alcohol taxes along with enterprise funds (water and sewer funded by fees) to make up the difference in our $70 million-plus operating budget.

We are going to hear that our leadership is paid too much money, causing your property taxes to go up. Well, we have already addressed what your property taxes pay for, but let's talk about your city employees.

The administration including the department heads are responsible for managing the equivalent of a $70 million-plus business. They are managing 300-plus employees and answering to the public. Each Department head is the equivalent of the CEO of a small company. Let's just take the Street Department.

Tim Martin is responsible for miles of streets. He has to keep them repaired, clean and clear of snow in the winter and leaves in the fall. He has to buy and maintain enough equipment to do the job, he has crews repairing streets, sidewalks. He also is responsible for maintaining all the City vehicles including police cars as well as all of the heavy equipment such as loaders and dump trucks. He has to manage a budget, estimate how much gas he will use, how much beet juice to buy to melt ice, how much maintenance will be required for equipment throughout the year.

Or let's take the Parks Department. Due to Doug's retirement, Bill Greenwood will be taking care of parks. Again, how much water, how much fertilizer, how heavy is the use going to be, how many seasonal employees, how many full-time employees, arranging for permits to use the parks ... Then you add the cemetery management along with some of the more complicated natural open space parks, Tubbs Hill and the Centennial Trail.

Let's talk about the departments that have fewer employees. Human Relations has two employees along with Pam McDonald, the department head. This department is responsible for hiring, contracts, dealing with unions and employee organizations. They are in charge of all employee relations, Insurance and benefits. They have to understand and be prepared to deal with the state and federal laws regarding public employees. They advise the administration and the mayor and council on employee issues.

How about our Police Department and our Fire Department? Here are some interesting facts. Chief Wayne Longo manages the largest department in the city. His people are responsible for more than just law enforcement. They also manage all events such as the Fourth of July, Ironman, etc. Our police chief is not only managing his staff, but also budget, how much gas, how many hours in court requiring overtime, how to provide the best service encouraging his people in a very difficult job.

Our fire chief, Kenny Gabriel, is managing the second largest department in the city. Fire trucks, fire boat, wildland fire management, EMS and on and on. You already know how challenging managing the budget is and what it entails, but Chief Gabriel's department is recognized as one of the top departments in the state. Our firemen are continually updating their training to provide you the best public safety available. When we recruit for fire department jobs, we get well over 100 applications, sometimes as high as 200; same for police. So what do we get when we hire? THE BEST OF THE BEST.

Just recently at a council meeting, a motion was made to deny a 2 percent cost of living increase and any merit increases in pay to department heads only. Just to clarify, the total of all the 2 percent increase amounted to less than $40,000. Only one department head was eligible for merit pay. The excuse for this was that it would help reduce property taxes. Frankly, I am not sure how this would impact your property taxes, but it certainly made our department heads feel less valued. The motion failed with a 4-2 vote.

People want to work for the City of Coeur d'Alene, we provide good jobs with opportunities to work your way up in your profession. The single most important reason for this is the management of the city, those CEOs, those administrators and department heads who answer to a Board of Director (Mayor and Council) and to you the taxpayers for everything they do. Most of them have worked their way up to their present positions, starting out at lower pay, just as those in the private world do. Some of them are retiring and we are really going to miss their skills and talents. And we will be hiring to replace them, but those new hires for the most part will start out at a lower wage. They have to work their way up too.

Am I proud of them and honored to work with them? You bet, and you should be too.

Deanna Goodlander is a Coeur d'Alene City Council member.

More about

More about

More about

  • Discuss

Welcome to the discussion.


  • Scottys_Neighbor posted at 9:21 pm on Sun, Sep 22, 2013.

    Scottys_Neighbor Posts: 37



  • Rogue Cop posted at 1:31 pm on Sun, Sep 22, 2013.

    Rogue Cop Posts: 2353

    A "city of vision"? Yeah, a narrowly defined the exclusion of anybody else's vision. How bout "CdA: Proud to be myopic"?

  • dfg posted at 5:58 pm on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    dfg Posts: 149

    I once compared Mrs. Goodlander to the teacher who should've retired along time ago but is tenured and sticks around for the benefits. She proved me right again.

  • concernedcitizen posted at 5:29 pm on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    concernedcitizen Posts: 2530

    OMG Your elitist "we know what is best for you" attitude is so unbecoming.

    Please tell us madam soon to be EX council woman, did/do you own property at Ramsey around where the crock church was partially funded with TAXPAYERS funds?

    You brag about the commercial corridor (I think you called it education) that was the HIGHEST paid for land in the state of Idaho using an BOGUS insider appraisal ALONG with a manipulation of lease agreement to keep the taxpayers out of the loop.

    What about the swapping of land that sold for WAY more than it should have for the library? Who owned that land that was swapped?

    You threw Riverstone in there. Failing over priced upscale condos off of the river just to later have "LOW INCOME" apartments thrown in the buyers faces ON the river topped off with a McDonalds at the entry when there is one a mile and a half away. Nothing says high end like McDonalds.

    Then McEuen, OH McEuen. Where to start. $40 million. "No, we will spend "NO MORE THAN $14 million" now $22 MILLION. Check the minutes madam soon to be EX council woman.

    Jobs....... $3.35 per hour SLAVE jobs. There has been such a hostile environment, even tax wise, that it is doubtful any credible company will ever settle in CdA. But, that is what the elitist want isn't it? You don't want those low life working class mucking up YOUR city, your "VISION". That is why the "VISIONARIES" drove out every livable wage job in the area. I hope you are proud of that legacy.

    All we, the taxpayers, ever asked for was accountability. Something this city leadership knows NOTHING about. Teague may vote for the clone Widmyer. I want you know his vote WILL be cancelled out. I trust NO ONE that has recently in the past five or so years that has purchased property in and around ANY of your UR projects. We already went through this with LCDC board members, council members and family members of...

    While you pat yourself on the back, I do hope the door gives you a good swift kick in the --- on your elitist way out.

  • Jullee posted at 3:59 pm on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    Jullee Posts: 541

    Whoa..Deanna, Really ???? !!! There you go again, telling us that only you know what is best for the rest of us.
    Everyone here that writes there is not enough space to reflect on your arrogant article are correct. Thought you were supposed to be on the "Humanity Council"
    You don't seem so humane in your statements here.
    You also gave us a financial break down. Sounds like we don't have enough money to fund your pet projects. I love magic math. Is that why the city goes into debt and pays interest for money we don't have. What a waste of hard earned money to the rest of us.

  • Humanist posted at 11:48 am on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    Humanist Posts: 3107

    Quote Spikey: " there is not enough time or space to refute, point by point, your comments"

    A blanket statement like that generally translates to actually not being able to provide a refutation.

  • Spikey posted at 9:50 am on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    Spikey Posts: 364

    Deanna, Deanna, there is not enough time or space to refute, point by point, your comments. Try self serving, politically motivated, blather. One finds it totally impossible to give you credence, let alone respect. Oblivion Deanna, go there, stay there....PLEASE

  • Scottys_Neighbor posted at 9:00 am on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    Scottys_Neighbor Posts: 37

    Remove the first paragraph throwing people under the bus and you have a fine, albeit redundant, synopsis of city progress.

    Or it was just a well intentioned political plug disguised as a pat on her own back.

    Because of that first paragraph I'm leaning toward the latter.

  • LTRLTR posted at 8:54 am on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    LTRLTR Posts: 1171

    LOL I meant pot shots not pot shops.

  • Miketeague posted at 8:22 am on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    Miketeague Posts: 2181

    Ms. Goodlander, I know you needed an opening for you letter and I guess my opinion is as good as anyone else to complain about. However you did fail to notice that I referred to the other side as ‘far right”. I know that the city has done some good things but do you really think bragging about using taxpayer money to build a church (the reader board out front refers to Kroc Church) is a good idea? You also brought up Riverstone, didn’t a large portion have to be auctioned off to avoid bankruptcy? Again not a good idea.
    Now I am not experienced in police dept’s or parks, but I am experienced in fire dept’s. the last battalion I worked in had 6 stations not 3, within the stations were 2 truck companies, 6 engine companies, 5 medic/ ambulances staffed by 2 firefighter medics each, (that did not charge for service), 2 haz mat units, 1 fire marshal, 6 inspectors and 2 Battalion Chiefs. The division which we were part of added another 12 stations with a Firefighter/medic on each engine. This division was only one third of the dept and the Department Chief made about the same as CDA’s Chief, you can’t blame unions on this because we belonged to the very same union and this was in California, you know the high pay state. So of course one has to wonder?
    Now even though I more often then not disagreed with your decisions which is okay, can’t please all the people all the time, I do wish you good luck in you retirement. And hope that Widmyer and your replacement can bring this city back together.

  • LTRLTR posted at 7:09 am on Fri, Sep 20, 2013.

    LTRLTR Posts: 1171

    Wow Deanna! What a perfect time to take pot shops at our citizens after you decided not to run for office again! This type of activity is disgusting from our elected officials and I sure hope the citizens stand up against people like you.

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Not you?||
Logout|My Dashboard