The great kokanee comeback - Coeur d'Alene Press: Local News

The great kokanee comeback

Glory days of popular fish might be near again

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, April 21, 2010 12:00 am

COEUR d'ALENE - Pete Thompson remembers when kokanee were so abundant in Lake Pend Oreille, when they fed in the evening, it looked like the water's surface was boiling.

"Lake Pend Oreille was one of the best fisheries in the world, with huge numbers of kokanee," said Thompson, who has lived in Sandpoint since 1960. "People came from all over the world to fish here."

But it has been decades since kokanee swam so rampantly, decimated by predator fish since then.

In fact, it has been around 10 years since anglers could take one home from the lake, although that may be changing in the future, the Idaho Department of Fish and Game said.

Fishermen could even start pulling kokanee from the lake again in two or three years.

"We're keeping our fingers crossed," said Chip Corsi, IDFG regional supervisor. "If we maintain the survival rates that we have, it's looking up."

The rebirth is attributed to the success of the netting operations and the bounties paid to fishermen that suppress predator populations, as well as good lake level management.

Implemented four years ago and primarily funded by Avista and Bonneville Power, the spring and fall expeditions have thinned lake trout populations dramatically, allowing kokanee to flourish - again.

The best mark of success is the rise in kokanee survival from 1- and 2-year-old fish populations. Those younger fish had a 10 percent survival rate in 2007. In 2009, Corsi said, it jumped to 69 percent.

Last year, the 1-year-old age class was still pretty weak, so getting high survival is particularly important, said Jim Fredericks, IDFG regional fishery manager.

And Fish and Game is keeping a close eye on how those younger fish do.

If they survive a couple more years, they'll be able to spawn, Fredericks said.

"This will be a very big year for the fish," Fredericks said. "If they make it, then the population by-and-large should be stable."

It won't be the 1 million or so annual harvest that the lake used to offer, but it could be a roughly 200,000 harvest, which could boost the $17 million sport fishing brings to the area each year.

"I think it would be very, very popular," Tina Padgitt of Black Sheep Sporting Goods in Coeur d'Alene said of fishing in large numbers for kokanee on Lake Pend Oreille.

The rise in kokanee could be thanks to netting and angler incentive practices.

"We are essentially crushing the adult lake trout population," Corsi said of the non-native fish known to be feasting on kokanee.

This spring IDFG pulled out more than 10,000 juvenile lake trout through netting. The 2009 kokanee population was near 80,000 for the first time since 2006. During that rise, lake trout spawning population has declined by more than 70 percent.

Since 2006, more than 99,000 lake trout have been removed from Pend Oreille. About half of those were taken by anglers, but the net catch has been taking the biggest portion in the past year.

As part of its licensing agreement with the Cabinet Gorge Dam, Avista and BPA will pay around $700,000 this year between the netting and bounty programs.

The Avista agreement is 10 years into the 45-year accord and netting and monitoring will likely continue for that time, the IDFG said.

Not on the IDFG radar for either method is walleye fish - at least not yet, the department said.

"We're concerned about walleye," Corsi said, adding that they netted 42 walleyes last year, and a couple dozen in 2010, but the fish is far down on the predator list.

Recently, a commercial fishing contractor retained by Fish and Game has been setting up a gill net overnight at the mouth of the Pack River to gain some insight on the influence of walleye in Pend Oreille.

"They're more of a peripheral issue for right now," Corsi said. "We'll just have to see how it plays out."

Of particular concern to the department is the potential impact walleye could have on rainbow and cutthroat trout, in addition to endangered bull trout emerging from the Pack and Clark Fork rivers. Walleye are piscivorous, which means they like to eat other fish.

But Thompson, an Idaho Fish and Game commissioner from 1972 -1983, said the department should lay off collecting walleye.

They're non threatening to kokanee populations, he said, hanging out in the shallower waters while kokanee swim in deeper parts of the lake. The two species co-exist in plenty of other waters, he added, and walleye make great fishing, a pleasure since the kokanee catch is off limits now.

"I love fishing for them," he said of walleyes. "They're pretty challenging fish to catch, but they're the best eating fish you'll ever catch."

More on the radar for IDFG is how the 1-year-old kokanee class does this year.

That population could be the key to whether Lake Pend Oreille has another kokanee harvest in the future.

"We're very, very encouraged," Fredericks said.

More about

  • Discuss

Welcome to the discussion.


  • web_hosting posted at 11:40 am on Thu, Apr 28, 2011.

    web_hosting Posts: 113

    Good to see fishing might be back to the glory days. Seems like it has been rough for awhile, so nice to see that it's getting better and to expect more.

    Web Hosting
    Singapore Web Hosting

  • web_hosting posted at 7:38 pm on Tue, Apr 19, 2011.

    web_hosting Posts: 113

    that's a great comeback they had. Congrats for the return.

    Web Design
    Singapore Web Design

  • web_hosting posted at 9:39 am on Sat, Apr 16, 2011.

    web_hosting Posts: 113
  • Internet Marketing posted at 7:51 pm on Thu, Apr 14, 2011.

    Internet Marketing Posts: 46

    I'm curious about kokane. How does it taste? Appreciate the information. Keep us updated. Thanks.
    Internet Marketing
    Web Marketing

  • Idaho Roper posted at 3:40 pm on Thu, Apr 22, 2010.

    Idaho Roper Posts: 117

    Oh brother.... Where to start. Now, we have yet another non native species showing up in the lake, and we have yet again, another F&G person saying, they will do no harm.
    Kokanee recovered? I won't hold my breath, I hope no one at F&G takes offense.
    A little history for those not aware.
    LakeOreille Pend
    Native species: West Slope Cutthroat, Bull trout, Kokanee, White Fish.
    Non Native Species: Kamloops Trout, Mackinaw (Lake trout), Mysis Shrimp, all introduced by who? ID F&G
    And now the walleye, hmmmm. I wonder how that got in their? Did ID F&G release this fish? I don't know for sure, so I won't point the finger at them, but I will be searching for an answer.

    Priest Lake
    Native Species: West Slope Cutthroat Trout, Bull Trout
    Non-Native Species: Mackinaw (Lake Trout), Kokanee, Mysis Shrimp. you guessed it, all introduced by none other than ID F&G

    The effects of this biologist created mess. The Bull Trout is listed as threatened and the West Slope Cutthroat is listed as a species of concern. Both species were abundant and thriving before the 'improvements' made by the biologists at F&G

    They have manipulated the natural spawning schedule of the kokanee in Pend Oreille to try and avoid the problem of the mysis shrimp being a direct competitor with the native fish in the fry stage, they have spend thousands and thousands and thousands of dollars trying to undue their actions and remove species they, themselves introduced. And yet they are STILL trying to blame everyone and everything but themselves.

    Give them a few more years and we'll be able to rename the our lakes. The Dead Seas of Idaho.

    The ID F&G is directly responsible for the destruction of three of our lakes in the panhandle alone. They have done the very same mismanagement of Coeur d' Alene lake, as we now have a free spawning non-native chinook salmon they were sure they could control also.

    And lets not even mention Pike, and their willingness to 'manage' this non-native as a game fish, much to the demise of several species of native fish. Or the fact they planted Rainbow trout in Hayden lake, much to the detriment of the native cutthroat. Or the planting of Eastern Brook trout in our streams that have reduced our native fishes habitat to spawn in traditional habitat.

    Seems everything they touch as a whole lot of negatives and a huge price tag attached. Yet, they all seem to keep their jobs.

    So, those of you at F&G, please don't be offended when I am skeptical anytime you claim to have 'fixed' ANYTHING!

    And we didn't even touch on the subject of our game.........

  • sparky 71 posted at 11:52 pm on Wed, Apr 21, 2010.

    sparky 71 Posts: 1

    Hey Tom, Do you remember back in the early 90's when a CALIFORNIA transplant came up here, and i believe was or is still working for AVISTA and let the flood gates open. I believe if you did some research in your papers archives, YOU would find some articales that possibly YOU have written that would say this "so called person" drained the" Lake Pend Oreille" of its tributaries in which "OUR" Kokanee spawn, leaving them no place to "RAISE THEIR YOUNG". For what, a profit to AVISTAS account? This so called BOUNTY that you praise AVISTA for has done nothing for our people nor the econimy. The IDFG should reclaime the lake and let AVISTA find another way to supply power to our communities, after all they are a "FOR PROFIT" company, Avista can do better than $700,000. For the lake trout, these species, the "KAMLOOPS" were the prize that brought the dividends to the community, not the Kokanee. The "Kokanee" were the feed for the "monies" that were brought into the mouths of the dollar hoarders. Let's take you back to when a "DEVELOPER" dredged a well known Kokanee spawning bed, What did he suffer, A fine, and then fix what MOTHER NATURE has done for years? How can that happpen?

    Now, let's look at Lake Couer d' Alene? Dont you think that history is repeating itself?
    come on now Tom "LETS HAVE THE TRUTH!!"

  • cd'a res posted at 10:40 am on Wed, Apr 21, 2010.

    cd'a res Posts: 1

    Beautiful picture!

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Not you?||
Logout|My Dashboard