Animal cruelty bill may lack bite - Coeur d'Alene Press: Local News

Animal cruelty bill may lack bite

Legislation might make dog fighting a misdemeanor

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, February 29, 2012 12:15 am

A legislative bill to make animal cruelty a felony includes language that would reduce dog fighting from a felony to a misdemeanor crime, a North Idaho activist pointed out this week.

SB1303, which passed the Senate last week, includes an amendment that would make third violations of any provision in Idaho's animal care statute - except for animal cruelty - a misdemeanor, noted Tony Mangan, president of Panhandle Equine Rescue, Inc.

Dog fighting is included in that blanket misdemeanor penalty.

"They did not exempt it from the bill," said Mangan, a Spirit Lake resident and also co-founder of Idaho 1 Of 3. "That puts (the Legislature) in a unique position."

He worries that if dog fighting is no longer a felony, it would become more common in the region. It would also be a black eye for the state, he said, as Idaho was one of the last two states to make dog fighting a felony four years ago.

"A lot of things go on around that kind of behavior, like the killing of dogs afterward," Mangan said.

His group, 1 Of 3, has also been fighting the bill because of its lack of mandatory sentencing. Prior to the Legislature authoring SB1303, the group has been collecting signatures to put its own initiative on the ballot to make animal cruelty a felony.

Karen Williams, Kootenai County animal control officer, said she would not support a reduced penalty for dog fighting.

"Because of the horrific nature of it," she said. "That's a horrible thing to do."

In her five years in her position, Williams said the sheriff's department has never had a dog fighting case.

She wasn't sure if changing the penalty would impact how often dog fighting occurs.

"With the caliber of person doing it, I'm not sure it would make a difference," she said.

SB1303 passed the senate 31-1 last week, with two absences and a vacant seat. It was introduced the next day to the House Agriculture Affairs Committee.

Rep. Tom Trail, who helped author the bill and is a member of House Agriculture Affairs, stated that the concern about reducing the dog fighting penalty "is an excellent point," and he plans to oppose that part of the bill.

The Moscow lawmaker said it's possible to handle the issue with an amending order.

"(Dog fighting) is one bill with the governor's help that we got passed about four years ago, and I don't want it to go down the drain," Trail wrote in an email.

Most of what Trail has advocated for animal safety is in SB1303, he said, though he would like to add a definition of animal torture with stricter penalties.

"My hope is that we can get this through this session and if we have to toughen it up, do it next session," Trail stated.

But the bill might not have a strong future anyway, said Rep. Phil Hart.

The Athol legislator noted that past bills to beef up animal mistreatment penalties have not garnered wide legislative support.

He hasn't read the bill yet, he said, but would approach it with caution.

"I think we need to be very careful in what kinds of penalties we add to the Idaho code," Hart said. "Our prisons have been overflowing, and we've had to send prisoners out of state and pay extra for that."

More about

More about

More about

  • Discuss

Welcome to the discussion.


  • wangyi posted at 12:47 am on Wed, Mar 7, 2012.

    wangyi Posts: 42

    Coach Outlet If you email us, we will answer you in 24hours online. New condition within 7 days of purchase for a full product refund. Product may not be returned in used condition unless defective by manufacturer's warranty.louis vuitton singapore Les gens qui n’ont aucune conscience de leur propre morphologie; les nanas qui ne savent pas marcher en talon et qui s’obstinent (surtout celles qui ne font pas refaire leurs embouts de talons et qui marchent en faisant clic, clic, clic) et surtout, SURTOUT,Coach Factory Online les filles qui portent des leggings sans rien d’autre.Je ne magasine pas en ligne. J’achète ce que je peux essayer.

  • JAC posted at 7:36 pm on Wed, Feb 29, 2012.

    JAC Posts: 5

    Representative Hart's comment in the article, "I think we need to be very careful in what kinds of penalties we add to the Idaho code," Hart said. "Our prisons have been overflowing, and we've had to send prisoners out of state and pay extra for that." Wow! So Hart's biggest concern is the fact that our Idaho prisons are overcrowded and by changing the law to make animal cruelty a felony, he is concerned that we would be adding more people to the prisons which would cost us more money because we have to ship them out-of-state because we don't have room? Really? So, this must mean there are a lot of people abusing animals that would hopefully be put in prison for committing the crime? Well then, if Hart thinks there are a good number of people abusing animals I guess we do need to make animal cruelty a felony! Wake up Idaho, animal cruelty, neglect and abuse (in any form) are very serious issues! We are one of four states where animal cruelty is not considered a felony. Unacceptable and shame on us!

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Not you?||
Logout|My Dashboard