OPINION: DR. MIKE MAY — The other side of the gun

Print Article


Growing up in Texas, I never gave much thought to the guns I encountered. No, there werenít six-shooters on everyoneís hips, and my classmates and I didnít ride horses to school, but yes, there were gun racks in trucks in the high school parking lot. There were guns in my dadís closet, and I shot enough to have lost some high frequency hearing, but that was my sense of normal.

During my surgical residency in Dallas, I began to understand what happens on the other side of a gun. Not a single ďtrauma callĒ day elapsed without at least one, and sometimes up to 10, patients with gunshot wounds being brought to Parkland Hospital, where I spent every third night for five years. From the perspective of a surgical trainee, this was a fantastic way to learn my lifeís work; many lives were saved, but many others were lost.

One day, as part of a trauma rotation, I went to ďGround West,Ē the part of Parkland where the pathology department, and thus the morgue, was located. The idea was to gain understanding of what we as surgeons hadnít been able to accomplish, to see what might be done the next time, for the next patient, to secure a better outcome.

I looked down on a boy who was 15 years old and would never be 16. He looked like he was sleeping, but with two holes in his chest and one in his head, there would be no waking up. Iíll never forget the paradox of the dead boy and his live, ticking watch. I knew then, and know now, that guns kill.

Now Iím nearing 50, with three kids in CdíA schools. Iím the Trauma Medical Director at Kootenai Health. Our trauma program, of which the community can be proud, saves lives. My colleagues and I train for but collectively dread the day we are called upon to treat victims of a mass shooting in our community. Sadly, I expect that awful day will, at some point, be upon us. On that day, we will bear the terrible burden of telling parents that their children are gone. Sixty-one percent of local teachers donít want guns in classrooms. Boise schools, Idaho sheriffs and police chiefs donít want guns in classrooms. Next time it comes up for possible adoption, likely in 2020, some legislators will again refuse to listen to the people this law would directly affect. Why?

Many readers may not be aware that Idaho school boards already have the authority to decide at the local level whether to arm their educators. A few rural communities have, in fact, done so.

Kootenai Health, the countyís largest employer, is a gun-free zone, as are our schools. Would you feel comfortable with your physician or nurse being armed as they lean over you to offer their care? I am certainly more comfortable knowing you arenít armed as I do my best to help in your time of need.

I am aware of many well worn responses you might be thinking of as you read this, but I can critically address a few, as in my work I must deal with evidence-based practices to ensure good outcomes.

• Itís simply NOT true that Israeli teachers are all armed.

• Itís NOT been shown beyond individual, anecdotal reports that more good guys with guns would stop more bad guys with guns.

• It HAS been shown that the presence of a gun in a home increases the risk of homicide by a factor of three and suicide by up to a factor of five.

• It IS true that where there are more guns, there are more gun-related deaths.

• It IS true that we have seen a 400 percent increase in gunshot wounds at Kootenai Health since 2016. Additionally, we have a disturbingly large number of gun-related suicides locally each year.

If guns are allowed in schools, how will we institute and monitor proper training and safe storage? Who will pay for such logistic imperatives? How will law enforcement be able to distinguish between an active shooter and those attempting to intervene with guns drawn? Finally, who will deliver the news to a parent that their child has been killed by an accidental discharge at school?

I do know the answer to that one. It will be me.


Mike May, M.D. is a Coeur díAlene resident and the trauma medical director at Kootenai Health.

Print Article

Read More My Turn

Education: Unleash free-market power

September 19, 2019 at 11:12 am | Coeur d'Alene Press At the end of the last century, something remarkable happened. The internet simultaneously exponentially increased the availability of knowledge and reduced the cost of acquisition to near zero. ...


Read More

17th century system fails 21st century students

September 18, 2019 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press Second of three parts Are Idaho public schools performing? That is a hot topic question, especially during election season. To answer that we must ask what is the mission of our public schools; wh...


Read More

OPINION: Education funding out of whack

September 17, 2019 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press Why donít Idaho teachers make $216,000 a year? It is a valid question as Idaho spends about $7,500 a year per student, supplemental levies add about $1,500 per student, and the average class size i...


Read More

The road to better education starts here

September 14, 2019 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press A quarter of a century is very long time. Unless youíre a road. Or a school. Twenty-five years ago this month Coeur díAlene got a new one of both. It all began in the early 1990s when the Coeur díA...


Read More

Contact Us

(208) 664-8176
215 N. Second St
Coeur d'Alene, Idaho 83814

©2019 The Coeur d'Alene Press Terms of Use Privacy Policy