Friday, November 20, 2026
36.0°F

OPINION: Will the Idaho GOP learn anything from the 2026 midterms?

by BECKY FUNK / The Idaho Way
| November 20, 2026 1:00 AM

The 2026 midterms brought sweeping changes to Congress, governorships, and state legislatures across the country. For months, political pundits predicted a blue wave. What Republicans got instead was a tsunami. And some of the party’s most prominent conservatives aren’t sugarcoating what happened.

Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich, architect of the 1994 Republican revolution and Contract with America, admitted letting his heart overrule his head when predicting the outcome. His assessment was remarkably candid: “First, we have to admit that we failed.”

Gingrich pointed to a fundamental disconnect between Republican messaging and the everyday concerns of voters. Families struggling with grocery bills, energy costs, and healthcare weren’t particularly interested in hearing how much worse Democrats might be. They wanted the solutions they were promised.

Texas Sen. Ted Cruz was considerably less diplomatic, calling the election a “Watergate-level repudiation.” He acknowledged that Republicans had failed to appreciate the financial pressures facing ordinary Americans.

Most striking, was conservative Congressman Chip Roy, who accused his own party of focusing on political power rather than the people who elected them. He argued that Republicans had become arrogant and lost sight of the people they were supposed to serve.

Three prominent conservatives. Three remarkably similar conclusions. Republicans weren’t listening. For me, the results in Texas were especially painful.

I spent the first half of my life in Texas and worked with Republican candidates as the state transitioned from blue to red. I watched Democrats lose their traditional voters as the party moved further away from values many Texans held dear. Now I’ve watched that political transformation reverse itself.

From conversations with friends who still live there, I don’t believe Texans suddenly embraced liberalism. I believe many simply got fed up with Republicans who seemed more interested in political battles than the problems facing their families. And Ken Paxton’s baggage certainly didn’t help. He was an albatross around the neck of every Republican vying for statewide office by causing voters to question the party’s judgment.

Texas didn’t turn blue because Republicans weren’t conservative enough. In fact, leadership has moved further and further to the right in recent years. Republicans lost because they took voters for granted, assuming anyone with an R beside their name was entitled to their vote.

So what does any of this have to do with Idaho? Quite a lot, actually. Idaho remains one of the reddest states in America, and Republicans comfortably retained statewide control. But that doesn’t mean we escaped the political fallout.

Democrats flipped four seats in the Idaho House and two in the Senate, increasing their legislative representation from 15 to 21 seats. They also improved their share of the vote in numerous districts across the state. Those aren’t numbers Idaho Republicans should casually dismiss.

There’s a lesson here for our state party, particularly those who confuse ideological purity with effective leadership. Voters want safe communities, good schools, affordable housing, responsible government, and elected officials who listen. They expect Republicans to govern competently and respect the people who put them in office.

Too often, Idaho GOP conversations revolve around loyalty tests, internal power struggles, and arguments over who qualifies as a “real Republican” or “true conservative.” Meanwhile, ordinary Idahoans are wondering whether their children will ever afford a home.

Being conservative doesn’t excuse being tone-deaf. Winning a Republican primary doesn’t guarantee the trust of every voter in November. Holding power isn’t the same as earning the right to keep it.

Idaho Republicans have an opportunity to learn from what happened elsewhere before voters deliver the same lesson here. The question isn’t whether Idaho is red enough.

It’s whether Republicans are listening closely enough to keep it that way.

• • •

Becky Funk is a member of North Idaho Republicans and former Legislative District 4 Republican Chair.


Logo

copyright © 2026 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy 215 N. 2nd St. Coeur d'Alene, ID 83814
208-664-8176

Coeur d'Alene Press BBB Business Review